Greetings, all CivFanatics, and welcome to the CivFanatics scenario review section.
Here, you will be able to read and submit reviews to all of your favorite scenarios on the internet.
We hope you enjoy this page, and we welcome your comments and suggestions, as well as your participation, for without YOU, there is no reason to have such features.
Currently, there are five permanent staff members for scenario reviews and submissions.
JValdezToo, who is also moderator of the CivFanatics scenario forum, is well known for his innovative and interesting scenario designs, and is well respected for his large body of mod pack and scenario work.
Kobayashi, threw the civ-2 Star trek fans on their collective ear with his excellent pair of scenarios, StarTrek: Battle of the Alpha Quadrant and Star Trek: Dominion war, and his latest release is ZWK, a European theater World War II scenario. Highly regarded for his innovative terrain and beautiful units, he has risen to be among the most highly regarded scenario designers around.
Willemvanoranje is a young designer who already has two impressive credits under his belt, his beautiful Dutch modpack, and his recently released Star Trek: Battle of the Kappa Quadrant. He is also well know as a playtester and has worked with some of the finer designers in the civilization scenario field.
SunTzu, who is a veteran moderator at CivFanatics, is considered one of the finest Playtester in the civilization scenario arena, has playtested numerous scenarios that have reached publication, and is quite exact in his evaluation of WW II scenarios, is a favorite playtester of Captain Nemo (Red Front, 2194 Days of War. ect).
Alcibiaties of Athenae is also a veteran playtester, who has worked with such designers as Jesus Balsinde, Jesus Munoz, Stefhan Hartel, Bernd Brosing, Prometius, Kobayshi, J Valdez II, Willemvanoranje, and Hodad, on many different scenarios.
It is our hope that we can provide the insight and experience to provide accurate reviews for the patrons of CivFanatics.com.
We welcome comments about our reviews and our review staff, and are always willing to listen to suggestions from the collective membership of CivFanatics.com.
These scenarios can be downloaded either from the Downloads page or the File Database.
Below you can find links to detailed reviews of individual scenarios, complete with images and score breakdowns.
- Afrika Korps
- Al-Andulas
- Ansteig
- Atlantis – The Lost Empire
- Brown Man’s Burden
- Colonization: The Struggle for Empire
- Enemy of God
- Imperium Romanum
- Justinian the Great
- Martian Dawn
- Of Celts and Iberians
- Seeds of Greatness: The Early Empires
- Sons of Heracles
- Star Contact: Part 1 – The Star Wars
- Star Trek: Dominion War
- Subwar
- The Cruel Sea
- The Quest for El Dorado
- Underdark
- Up the Deadly Boot
- Zhan Guo
- Zweiter Weltkrieg